To Wean or Not to Wean (And Other Uncertainties)


I thought I was done with perfectionism- and then I became a mom.

When I began the most important undertaking of my life, everything I had learned about the pitfalls of trying to do something “perfectly” went flying out the window. Of course, perfection is an unattainable goal when you are talking about a task as complicated as mothering.

I’ve been reminded of this fact many times. And while I thought I’d accepted that I’ll never achieve motherhood perfection, I’ve realized lately that I’m still paralyzed by the fear of making a mistake.

I struggled to breastfeed my son.

I fought through scary incidents and weeks of pain while breastfeeding to continue nourishing him this way. I didn’t do this because I thought formula was the wrong way to go (I’m firmly in the “nourish any way you choose without shame” camp); my son just wouldn’t take it when I offered.

Through all my doubts, frustrations, pain and struggles, we made it to a year of breastfeeding. My mom told me that both my brother and I just lost interest in nursing after a year and I thought it might be the same for my little. But that hasn’t been the case. In so many ways, I wish it had been, because the shame-inducing truth I am struggling with at the moment is that I don’t want to breastfeed anymore.

weanNoted research professor and TED talker Brene Brown defines shame as:

The intensely painful feeling or experience of believing that we are flawed and therefore unworthy of love and belonging – something we’ve experienced, done, or failed to do makes us unworthy of connection.

I guess when it comes down to it, I am scared that I am flawed because I want to wean, even though my son still wants/needs it and I’m still physically able. I’m scared that if I end that interaction because I need sleep or personal space, it will damage our relationship. And yet, I still want to do it.

Part of the security blanket I wrapped around myself to keep the new mom insecurities away early on involved always putting my son’s needs ahead of mine. Always.

But now that he is older, when my needs and his are seemingly at odds, whose wins?

Does what I need or want always have to give way to his needs and wants?

When and how do you strike the right balance of the two, knowing both are important?

And how do you take action when you aren’t sure?

In many ways, this reminds me of so many things I’ve struggled with in motherhood, where uncertainty and fear converge, where my desire to be close to my son and to teach him important lessons about life diverge. I guess I’ve got to let go of figuring out the “right way” to do things and start proceeding with hope that “right” or “wrong,” “perfect” or “flawed” my son will know how truly, deeply, and fiercely I love him.


Previous articleSafely Social: Keeping Your Family Safe on Social Media
Next articleOur Baby’s First Trophy
Like most mothers, Kate is many things. To name a few: Mama to Jack; Wife to Matt; Encinitas dweller, beach frequenter and future "Grom Mom"; coffee connoisseur, wine aficionado and foodie; Farmers' Market fanatic; perpetual explorer and lover of life. Kate believes that motherhood is both exquisitely beautiful and unbelievably hard sometimes. She hopes that her posts can spark inspiration to explore, share encouragement, and help San Diego moms make the most of living in "America's Finest City." You can find more of Kate's thoughts and experiences at


  1. I’m right there with you. I was hoping my LO would like eating solids by now so our nursing sessions would be fewer. I’m just waiting it out now….

  2. I totally understand! I had to wean my oldest when I found out I was pregnant. It was pretty easy because my milk basically dried up and she lost interest. With my younger daughter I couldn’t wait until she turned one! After three and a half years of either being pregnant or nursing, I wanted a break. We’ve been “weaning” for about two months now and she is down to just nursing all night long ? Being a mom is so tough but congrats on making it a year!

  3. Thanks for your honesty. I know most of us struggle with sometimes wondering when we can put ourselves first. This might sound cliche, but in 20 (or 30!) years you’ll miss it, even with all the struggles. Hang in their momma!


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here